This story is told differently from the point-of-view of Cupid plus Lindsay, Eleanor, and John. What do you like about these multiple points of view during a story?
Do you think John was right in waiting to tell Lindsay about his new relationship? Why or why not?
How do you think Eleanor handled Lindsay and John? Would you change anything?
Do you think Lindsay was being fair at the beginning of the story with her dad, John? Why or why not? How did it change over the course of the story?
Do you wish there was a real Cupid watching out over relationships? Why or why not?
Have you ever seen a pet that you just had to have? What was it and how did it work out?
Do you think Lindsay should have moved? Would you have done the same or stayed and tried to make it work?
How do you feel about Life Management? Does it help or hinder Cupid?
Do you know someone who is a matchmaker like Cupid? How successful are they at making good matches?
How do you think pets can help people deal with situations in life? Has there been a time in your life when a pet has helped you through something?